As a client with Choice Insurance Agency, you can be confident that you will have a personal experience. You’ll work with a team of trusted advisors that are focused on ensuring that you have the protection you need and the coverage that is easy to understand.

This focus begins with the executive leadership team, who draws on broad industry experience. They are genuine people that uphold the company’s core values of integrity, teamwork and professionalism. They have an ownership mentality and are growth-oriented, and they cherish life and making the most of it.

Steve Rice

President

Steve Rice has over 35 years of experience in the insurance industry including senior management roles in the national carrier, E&S broker, and independent agency sectors. Most recently Rice was a partner at Middle Peninsula Insurance Agency based in Williamsburg, VA. At Middle Peninsula, Rice was their CFO and COO responsible for managing their five locations, overseeing all financial actions, and leading their acquisition team. They sold to Towne Insurance in 2019. At Towne, Rice served as an Executive Vice President where he was responsible for the integration of Middle Peninsula into Towne, hitting earn out objectives and managing the day-to-day operations. He has worked with a regional carrier and insurance agencies consulting on various strategic measures. He has also served on several non-profit boards and committees.

Rice earned a BS Degree from Siena College and an MBA from Syracuse University. He lives in Williamsburg with his wife Robin. They have four grown children, one son-in-law, and one granddaughter. In his free time, he enjoys playing golf, boating, and serving as a volunteer in the community. 

Kelley Carter

Kelley Carter

President of Choice Insurance Agency

Steve Keogh

Steve Keogh

Managing Director of Choice Benefits and Broker Services

Gregg Kennerly

Gregg Kennerly

Senior VP of Sales

Millie Wilson

Millie Wilson

VP Administration

Kimie Porter

Kimie Porter

Chief Culture Officer

Timeia Brown

Timeia Brown

Executive Assistant to the C-Suite

Ian Jackson

Ian Jackson

Sr. Vice President of Finance